Friday, November 10, 2006

A Good Year (**3/4)


? London’s top stock trader (Russell Crowe), having unexpectedly inherited a French vineyard from the uncle who raised him, learns the joys of simple living and loving. Roughly, it’s Jerry McGuire crossed with Under the Tuscan Sun, as directed by Ridley Scott, who also directed Crowe in Gladiator. The script was adapted from Peter Mayle’s novel by the guy whose previous credit is the fluffy romantic comedy Serendipity.
+ The movie has a laid-back vibe that, along with nice scenery, mostly made it pleasant to watch. It was mostly free of the corny moments and overbroad supporting characters that made Under the Tuscan Sun seem too much like a bad sitcom set in a Busch Gardens version of Europe, although the hero does “meet cute” with the love interest (Marion Cotillard)—he nearly runs her over with his car. The flashback scenes, with Albert Finney playing the uncle, are well done, and I also liked the ones with Archie Panjabi (who’s a woman) as the faithful assistant back in London.
- It’s always tough to show a character changing and make it believable. I wasn’t convinced that Crowe’s character was, after a week in the country, a lecture from an unexpected visitor, and a look at the local hottie, ready to chuck it all, or to regard the aforementioned beauty as someone different from the succession of brief relationships he’s apparently had in England. Even those flashbacks, which curiously all seem to take place the same summer, reveal a boy who was smart but already a cheater (at chess) and a sore loser. Why is he going to change?
= **3/4 Diverting but superficial. The romantic aspects aren’t emphasized enough to call this a romance, and there aren’t enough existential aspects to call it deep.

No comments:

Post a Comment