-->? The place is Philadelphia in the age of plaid, when the O’Jays (1974) and Philly soul ruled the charts. Unable to land a job as a math teacher, former college swimmer Jim Ellis (Terrence Howard) takes a job at the run-down Marcus Foster Recreation Center, which is about to be shut down by the city. There, he starts a team that proves that black kids really can swim.
+ The best things
here are Howard and the character he plays. While the storyline is heavily
fictionalized, it’s true to Ellis’s modest, unassuming way. As a profile of
Ellis in February 14’s Philadelphia City Paper put it, “When there was
racism, he taught his swimmers to recognize it, then rise above it.” Bernie Mac
lends some gentle humor as the rec center’s other employee. The pacing is good.
-
Pride strains so hard to be inspirational, as the title suggests, that it feels
false. The plotting seems convenient rather than believable. Take, for example,
how Ellis supposedly gets his team. One day, a city worker takes down the
basketball net outside Foster where five friends like to play. Lo and behold,
all five agree to transform themselves into a swim team. Gee, not one of them
says, no thanks, I’m not that into swimming? Tom Arnold is the cartoon racist
who won’t hire Ellis to work at the preppy “Main Line Academy.” Lo and behold,
not only is he the head of the school, but he also coaches the swim team, which
just so happens to be the best in the Northeast corridor, thus the eventual
rival to Ellis’s team. There’s a cartoon criminal too, singlehandedly representing
the element Coach Ellis is trying to help the kids resist. He’s so generic you
can barely tell if he’s a drug dealer (as I assumed) or a moonshiner, and the
scene where the coach faces him down is way corny. The students themselves are
underwritten characters, and there’s hardly anything about swimming or Ellis’s
actual coaching techniques.
= **1/4 I’ll admit
that the preview audience seemed to like this from the comments I overheard,
and it certainly left me in a pleasant mood, but since about a dozen of these
“inspirational” BOATS (based on a true story) movies come out every year, there
are better ones to watch. Recently preceding this were Invincible, another
Philly sports story that was actually partly filmed there, and Freedom
Writers, which isn’t a sports movie but covers the raising-up-urban-youth
angle. You want both? Watch The Gridiron Gang.
IMDb link
IMDb link
No comments:
Post a Comment